Jump to content
270soft Forum


  • Content Count

  • Joined

  • Last visited

  • Days Won


RFK/JFKfan last won the day on April 26 2012

RFK/JFKfan had the most liked content!

Community Reputation

11 Good

About RFK/JFKfan

  • Rank
    Political Guru

Recent Profile Visitors

The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.

  1. What are some examples of prominent elections that have either never been made into scenarios or have only had half-baked scenarios? As a Britisher who has been aware of these games since 2008, I can't recall the 2001 general election ever having been made into a scenario on any version. Understandable in a way as it was probably the most boring since universal suffrage, but it does offer some potentially interesting alternative leader scenarios (like if the Tories had been led by Clarke or Portillo) and it the percentages compared to 1997 might not require much tweaking. Pre-1979 s
  2. Presidents: 1. Obama 2. Clinton 3. Trump (as of yet he's more of a Harding than a Nixon) 4. W. Bush Nominees: 1. Obama (excellent campaigner, one of the best ever) 2. W. Bush (captured the national spirit of the times, at least where it mattered) 3. Kerry (would have been a winner if not for a lack of charisma) 4. Trump (unprofessional...but managed to tap into something that perhaps no other Republican could have done so that year. The fact that the 'something' is quite ugly is besides the point, IMO, for this ranking) 5. McCain (the Palin pic
  3. My favourite moment was when Bernie gave short shrift to Steyer just after his argument with Warren.
  4. He's starting to channel Harold Stassen.
  5. Bill Clinton - Charismatic Al Gore - Uncharismatic George W Bush - Likeable Dick Cheney - Uncharismatic John Kerry - Uncharismatic John McCain - Likeable Mitt Romney - Charismatic (in a somewhat artificial way) Sarah Palin - Charismatic Barack Obama - Charismatic Joe Biden - Likeable Donald Trump - Unlikeable Mike Pence - Likeable John Kasich - Likeable Ted Cruz - Unlikable Marco Rubio - Likeable Jeb Bush - Uncharismatic Bernie Sanders - Likeable Hillary Clinton - Unlikeable Tim Kaine - Likeable Pet
  6. The hype about Walker was the most justified of these on the basis of substance. even though he was probably the least charismatic of them. O'Rourke was hyped because of his looks and youth, Bush because of his name, Perry for being the long-time governor of a big state and Clark for his military experience.
  7. One can always be fairly certain when one of these rankings comes out that Lincoln, FDR and Washington (in whatever order) will occupy the top spots while the bottom will be crammed with various mid-19th century presidents.
  8. It's a shame, although not surprising given the niche nature of the subject, just how few electoral/psephological simulators there are.
  9. If Biden has Reagan's political skills (thinking quite specifically here of Reagan's response to the age question in one of his debates with Walter Mondale), then it will be less of an issue. But I'm not entirely sure he does.
  10. 1) Considering Boris Johnson has suffered two defeats by Parliament, defections in his party, and is the first PM to lose power to parliament since 1894 (or is it 1896), how would you rank Boris Johnson as Prime Minister if his premiership ended today? If it ended today, he would be a failure on his own terms. If you don't achieve the fundamental goal that you promised when you entered the job, then you can't be regarded as anything else. Blaming those who oppose Brexit is akin to blaming the enemy when you lose a war. 2) Who has been the worst Conservative PM since they took power?
  11. This seems like a "other than that, how was the play Mrs Lincoln?" kind of statement. There's a very real chance that his decision to make the referendum pledge in 2013 (which he didn't expect to have it keep, thus making it even worse) may lead to the break-up of the United Kingdom. It has already caused levels of political polarization approaching those seen in the United States. Brown was worse for the Labour Party than he was for the country. He actually handled the biggest issue of his premiership (the financial crash) well. May was probably never going to be a success g
  12. Indeed, and Taylor's body was exhumed for the purposes of this theory. This was the inspiration for the Simpsons episode 'Lisa the Iconoclast'.
  13. Except of course that life expectancy was 20 years or more lower in nineteenth century USA than it is now. Higher infant mortality rates do make the statistics on this somewhat misleading, but nonetheless, fifteen presidents have passed away prior to reaching the age of 70 without the assistance of an assassin's bullet. Of these, fourteen (or thirteen if you discount Theodore Roosevelt, who did suffer at the hands of a gunman several years prior to his death) were born prior to 1900. Eleven presidents have reached the age of 80. This list is much more mixed, as it includes H. W. Bush, Ca
  14. Thatcher's cabinets were also much more impressive than May's. May's have included Priti Patel, Amber Rudd, Boris Johnson, Gavin Williamson, Matthew Hancock, Penny Mordaunt, Chris Grayling and Liam Fox. Thatcher's included Geoffrey Howe, William Whitelaw, Lord Carrington, Douglas Hurd, James Prior, Michael Heseltine, Keith Joseph, Nigel Lawson, Norman Tebbit, and John Major.
  15. Being a 70-something today is roughly equivalent to being a 40-/50-something in the time of Abraham Lincoln (who was 56 when he first took office). Putting aside age, however, many of the greatest presidents suffered from numerous health issues during their presidencies - FDR, Lincoln, JFK, Reagan, Eisenhower, to name the more obvious examples, and they encompass a fairly wide range of ages. Unless someone wishes to correct me, the likes of Buchanan, Pierce, W. Bush (also a fairly wide range of ages) etc had relatively smooth states of health during their times in office. As I said in an
  • Create New...